ELSTER error messages on the advance VAT return: causes and fixes
Do you get a message instead of the confirmation when you send your advance VAT return (UStVA)? Software sends the data to the tax authorities through the ERiC interface, and its check rules are published in the 2026 ERiC documentation. Here are seven messages in the wording of that documentation (in German, as ELSTER shows them), their cause and what to check.
Last updated: 20 November 2026
In brief
- Error or notice: The documentation separates the two. An error means the return cannot be sent as it is; a notice only asks you to check.
- Typical cause: Of two paired tax codes (tax base and tax), only one is filled in.
- Wording: The text in your program may differ slightly; the software fills in the field names itself.
„Die Felder 'Kz35' und 'Kz36' sind gemeinsam einzugeben“ (the fields must be entered together)
This is an error in the ERiC check rules, not a notice. The documentation lists it for seven pairs of tax codes: each code has a partner, and both must be filled in together. A user quotes the message in the ELSTER forum like this: „Bei der Datenübertragung ist ein Fehler aufgetreten. - Das Elstermodul der Finanzverwaltung meldet: Die Felder … Kz35 … und … Kz36 … sind gemeinsam einzugeben.“ Lexware support names as the cause „paarige Kennziffern, bei denen eine der beiden Positionen nicht befüllt ist“ (paired codes where one of the two positions is empty).
| Tax codes | Area according to the ERiC documentation |
|---|---|
| Kz35 and Kz36 | taxable supplies at other tax rates |
| Kz46 and Kz47 | other services of a business established elsewhere in the EU (§ 13b para. 1 UStG) |
| Kz73 and Kz74 | supplies covered by the GrEStG (§ 13b para. 2 no. 3 UStG) |
| Kz76 and Kz80 | supplies on which tax is payable under § 24 UStG |
| Kz84 and Kz85 | other services (§ 13b para. 2 nos. 1, 2, 4 to 12 UStG) |
| Kz94 and Kz96 | intra-Community acquisitions of new vehicles from suppliers without a VAT ID |
| Kz95 and Kz98 | intra-Community acquisitions at other tax rates |
Look in the report of your return for the pair that is only half filled, and check whether the missing amount is missing or the existing one is there by mistake. In accounting software, check the accounts: the tax base account and the tax account both need the matching code. For bookings under § 13b UStG, Lexware names another cause: if no tax case is assigned to the booking, the tax in Kz85 is missing from the return. In the forum (thread 359461, return for the first quarter of 2021) the answer was to check the settings of the accounts to which the 16 % sales were booked.
- Next step: Upload your Amazon or eBay reports – VAT GPT calculates your advance VAT return; with Pro you send it through ELSTER. Try it free.
„Bitte machen Sie Angaben im Feld 'Steuernummer'“ (please fill in the field "tax number")
This is also an error: the documentation requires the tax number to be given. The message reads „Bitte machen Sie Angaben im Feld '$Steuernummer$'“, and the software inserts the field name. The field is empty or was not sent. Enter the tax number the tax office assigned to you and send again. How to apply for it: apply for a tax number.
„Der angegebene Voranmeldungszeitraum liegt in der Zukunft“ (the period is in the future)
The full text reads: „Der angegebene Voranmeldungszeitraum liegt in der Zukunft. Die Steuern dürfen jedoch nicht für die Zukunft angemeldet werden. Bitte prüfen Sie Ihre Eingabe.“ (The period you entered is in the future. Taxes may not be declared for the future. Please check your entry.) The documentation classes the rule as a notice. It compares the year and period you chose in the form with today's date: if the period lies after today, the notice appears. Open the form again and check the year and period.
„Der angegebene Voranmeldungszeitraum ist noch nicht beendet“ (the period has not ended yet)
The full text: „Der angegebene Voranmeldungszeitraum ist noch nicht beendet. Bitte prüfen Sie Ihre Eingabe.“ The documentation also classes this as a notice. It appears when the chosen year is the current one and the chosen period is the current month or the current quarter. You file the advance return after the period has ended, by the 10th day after it; with a permanent extension, one month later. Check that you chose the right period in the form. How the deadlines run: filing the advance VAT return online.
„Der angegebene Steuerbetrag ist im Verhältnis zur Bemessungsgrundlage unwahrscheinlich“ (the tax amount is unlikely in relation to the tax base)
For Kz35 and Kz36 the text continues: „Bitte überprüfen Sie Ihre Eingabe zu steuerpflichtigen Umsätzen zu anderen Steuersätzen!“ This is a notice, not an error, and it exists for all seven pairs of tax codes; the second sentence names the area of each pair. For Kz35 and Kz36 the documentation says: if the tax base is greater than zero, the notice appears when the tax is above 19 % of the tax base plus 10 euros or below 5 % minus 10 euros. Check that the net amount and the tax amount are in the right fields and that the figures fit the tax rate.
„Bitte geben Sie Ihre Wirtschafts-Identifikationsnummer (W-IdNr.) an“ (please give your business identification number)
According to the documentation this is a notice, not an error. The rule only checks whether the field for the business identification number (W-IdNr.) is filled in. If the BZSt has notified you of one, you enter it.
„… wurde mit dem Wert 0 erklärt … die Erklärung von Nullwerten nicht erforderlich“ (declared with the value 0, zero values not required)
This is the zero-value notice. The documentation has it for many tax codes, for example Kz86 (tax base at the 7 % rate): „Die Bemessungsgrundlage ohne Umsatzsteuer für steuerpflichtige Umsätze zum Steuersatz von 7 % wurde mit dem Wert 0 erklärt. Da es sich nicht um eine Berichtigung der Anmeldung handelt, ist die Erklärung eines Nullwertes nicht erforderlich.“ It appears when a tax code is filled with 0 (for a pair: both codes) and the return is not marked as a corrected return (Kz10). It is a notice, not an error. More on a return without sales: advance VAT return: zero return.
- Next step: Upload your Amazon or eBay reports – VAT GPT calculates your advance VAT return; with Pro you send it through ELSTER. Try it free.
How VAT GPT helps
VAT GPT is the tax software for online sellers, freelancers and small businesses in Germany. It calculates and files in one place, in this order:
- your OSS return
- VAT
- EÜR
- trade tax
- income tax
- Upload: You upload your Amazon and eBay CSV reports and your invoices; VAT GPT calculates your advance VAT return from them.
- Check: You check and confirm the amounts before sending.
- Send: With VAT GPT Pro, the advance return goes through ELSTER directly to the tax office.
VAT GPT is listed in the software directory on elster.de; the details there come from the manufacturer. There is Free (basic functions, free), Go (30 days free with all Pro features) and Pro. Try for Free Now
Not tax advice: the content does not replace individual advice.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an error and a notice? The ERiC documentation lists the rule type for every check rule. An error means the return cannot be sent as it is. A notice asks you to check the entry.
Where do the messages come from? From the 2026 ERiC documentation, the table of plausibility checks for the advance VAT return. ERiC is the interface through which programs send data to ELSTER.
What does "gemeinsam einzugeben" mean? The documentation names seven pairs of tax codes, each a tax base and its tax. If one code of a pair is filled in, the other must be filled in too.
Do I have to change anything after a notice? Check the entry. In the documentation a notice is not an error message.
My message is not listed here. Give the wording to the support of your program or call the ELSTER hotline. This page only covers messages that appear in the documentation.